Amaro and Cream

Folks who really love their creamy drinks stick to old favorites like mudslides and holiday nogs because they’re familiar…but if you sub in Italian Amaro as a base for dairy-centric drinks—all bittersweet and herbal with notes of molasses, clove, and orange peel—you’ll turn an otherwise vegetal, spice-like liquor into something surprisingly kid-like. Now, since Italians are brave, they drink their Amaro neat, on the rocks, or in club soda as an aperitivo (a light pre-dinner beverage) and sometimes as a digestivo to settle the stomach. But mixing it with cream turns Amaro into a piquant desert-in-a-glass…a complex departure for adventuresome sippers who are bored with Bailey’s.

Makes 2 drinks


  • 4 ounces Amaro (Montenegro is one of the big-four common brands)
  • 4 ounces light or half-and-half cream
  • Nutmeg, freshly grated
  • Ice
  • Ingredients


  1. In a cocktail shaker or small bar pitcher with long stirring spoon combine the Amaro, cream, and ice. Shake until the shaker develops condensation on the outside, 15-20 seconds, or stir in glass pitcher, about 30 seconds. Pour into an ice-filled glass (preferably a lowball glass). Garnish with fresh nutmeg.

This recipe was featured on Season 24 - Episode 2426.

Print This Recipe


Chris Huisman

Who was your guest on this episode, 2426?

Leave a comment

Your comment will be revised by the site if needed.